
AI writing feedback improved revised drafts, while adding teacher feedback did not yield a clear overall advantage
Linqian Ding, Di Zou, Lucas Kohnke
Education and Information Technologies
A study of 77 graduate students in Hong Kong compared ChatGPT feedback with teacher-refined ChatGPT feedback on a literature-review assignment. Both groups improved their revised drafts. The combined approach produced a significant grammar advantage, but no significant overall improvement advantage between groups. Because the study assessed one assignment without an unaided transfer test, the findings concern revision quality rather than established long-term writing development.


